International Adoption Blog

11/23/07

African reality sans the adoption option

Posted by : Sandra Hanks Benoiton in International Adoption Blog at 04:36 am , 820 words, 1113 views  
Categories: Adoption Advocacy

With a family less than even a remote possibility for millions of African children, those who advocate for international adoption have a responsibility to stay abreast, as much as possible in a world where the mass of information is daunting, to say the least, of the reality of life in Africa.

Unlike some who insist that life is always better lived where begun, people who embrace the idea of a global village and families without borders see international adoption as one way some of the world's children can find love, life and happiness. Making this point requires frequent visits to info-wells that are darned uncomfortable to dip into, and so full of ugliness and horror that turning a blind eye could seem a sensible tact.

So it goes. Pretending all is roses and rainbows only helps the pretenders, and the more choosing that route, the less likely it is that any progress will be made. Change only happens when people are uncomfortable, and that often requires sticking a leg into the boiling tar of misery that is the real life of other people.

With that thought, I offer just a few of the stories making the world's news providers lately.

From Uganda, this about how peace is threatening children there. Refugee camps are closing, and with them the only home many orphans of war have ever known, along with the support systems the camps provided, as weak and sporadic as those may be.

Of course, life has not been easy in the camps with prostitution ... a tit-fot-tat that earns some the equivalent of eleven cents a throw ... abuse, theft and drugs the daily themes. No knowledge of "home villages", no living adult family members and such, however, leave other alternatives unlikely.

In Lesotho, there are some darned lucky kids. Some have some family ... only about half the students are double orphans, meaning both parents died, and of AIDS, and in this part of the world that's a hefty percentage of kids with parents ... and they go to school. It has no electricity and few desks or supplies, but the kids pack it out day after day.

The problem here is that there isn't enough food to go around.

"Drought has robbed the children's families of their crops this year. They come to school on empty stomachs. I honestly don't know where or when they are fed. These are the ones who nod off during class; they have no energy," the school's principal Francis Adewale, 39, a Nigerian national, told IRIN.

SPONSOR


Some orphans live with relatives who refuse them food. Some have no one. School is great, but starvation pays little attention math skills.

In Angola and other countries, some orphans are accused of being witches when their parents die suddenly or someone has an agenda that makes such accusations convenient.

In parts of Angola, Congo and the Congo Republic, a surprising number of children are accused of being witches, and then are beaten, abused or abandoned. Child advocates estimate that thousands of children living in the streets of Kinshasa, Congo’s capital, have been accused of witchcraft and cast out by their families, often as a rationale for not having to feed or care for them.

The officials in one northern Angolan town identified 432 street children who had been abandoned or abused after being called witches. A report last year by the government’s National Institute for the Child and the United Nations Children’s Fund described the number of children said to be witches as “massive.”


Sadly, this can be what happens to kids with living parents, parents who are unable to feed themselves and their families, often with fathers heavy into alcohol, who look for "any justification to expel them [children] from the family".

In addition to torture, death is frequently the outcome of being cast as a witch. There are shelters for some kids, all boys, if they manage to escape. There are no options for girls, however.

Children in orphanages can be subject to miseries heaped on them by those in charge, as this story from Zambia shows, and figuring out what happens to the millions of dollars supposedly marked for orphans isn't easy, either.

Across the board, virtually none of these children would be considered available for adoption. International families are not an option for the nine-year-old Ugandan prostitute, the 12-year-old Angolan "witch", the starving students in Lesotho. There is no shortage of people who from the comfort of their safe and well-fed lives claim vehemently that these kids must stay where they are, that removing them from the circumstance into which they were born amounts to nothing less that "cultural genocide", and that any efforts to open a path between them and foreign families would be some sort of ploy to create a market.

That's a handy dodge, but I wonder what the kids would have to say if anyone bothered to ask.

Photo credit

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
I tried to leave a comment earlier.

TO me it's like telling an abused child, "I'm sorry, but you'll just have to stay with your abusive parents as they are your parents and you'll be damaged if you are taken away from them."
It is true that it can be distressing to a child to be removed from their home but the damage is much worse if they are allowed to stay where each day they are hurt.
PermalinkPermalink 11/23/07 @ 17:29
Comment from: Yemi [Member] Email · http://www.dalianmitmita.com
I really think we need to differentiate between being poor and being abused (witches case vs not enough food case). First, on (hunger) is a common problem worldwide not just in Africa, the other isn't (the overwhelming majority of very poor African families love their children and don't accuse them of being witches).

It is important to note that, in countries like Ethiopia, one meal a day is a very common problem in times of trouble. The children do come to school hungry and that is why some development organizations try to provide food alongside schooling so that the kids can be better fed and able to pay attention to their schoolwork instead of their hunger pangs.

However, it doesn't mean these kids, in these families, aren't loved. Being poor doesn't equal to being available for adoption... do you know what I mean? In most cases, these families adamantly want to keep their children and go through the hardship together and hope to see a better day.

Also, the orphans. I can not discuss other African countries but I can again talk about Ethiopia because I am from there and I worked in the development field before moving to China.

Most orphans end up being taken in by the extended families. This largely works, I say largely because depending on the family dynamics, sometimes it can end up being a bad experience for the kid being taken in. Anyway, so, when mom and dad die, then usually the child goes to a relative's home to live.

So, there may be millions of orphans (no mom and dad) in Ethiopia but most are living with their extended families. Thus the creation of organizations that give a hand up to extended families who have taken in an orphaned child.

Kids who do not have these arrangements end up in orphanages and the streets. I hope these kids find a home with anyone willing to provide it anywhere in the world.

I suppose I am posting this response because I am a little disturbed that just simply being poor is lumped together with abuse of children in your post. That was probably not your intention but nonetheless the juxtaposition really disturbed me.

Hope you have a good day.
PermalinkPermalink 11/24/07 @ 09:06
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
I'm not sure if that was what I meant.
If a child does have extended relatives to care for them, it's different than a child in an orphanage or out on the street with no one to take care of them but a handful of overworked workers who can't give them what an extended family or adoptive family can give them.
It isn't fair in my eyes for authorities to limit these children from getting the families they need with red tape and a desire to save face.

But, there are judges and authorities here who will prevent a child from being adopted by their loving foster parents and give them back to abusive parents who haven't completed their reunification plans and have been given numerous chances to change.
That bothers me deeply.
PermalinkPermalink 11/24/07 @ 11:20
Comment from: Yemi [Member] Email · http://www.dalianmitmita.com
Chromesthesia, thank you for clarifying.

However, I am also talking about the original blog post itself. It talks about kids in Lesotho being hungry when they come to school. Then it talks about kids who are abused. Hunger and abuse are two different things.

Quote "In Lesotho, there are some darned lucky kids. Some have some family ... only about half the students are double orphans, meaning both parents died, and of AIDS, and in this part of the world that's a hefty percentage of kids with parents ... and they go to school. It has no electricity and few desks or supplies, but the kids pack it out day after day. The problem here is that there isn't enough food to go around."

And then there is a quote from a news article at IRIN "Drought has robbed the children's families of their crops this year. They come to school on empty stomachs. I honestly don't know where or when they are fed. These are the ones who nod off during class; they have no energy," the school's principal Francis Adewale, 39, a Nigerian national, told IRIN."

And then the writer goes on to say “Some orphans live with relatives who refuse them food. Some have no one. School is great, but starvation pays little attention math skills.”
Abuse and hunger are discussed in the same breath in the original article in essence saying all these kids should be up for adoption.

At the end of the article the blog writer goes on to say “Across the board, virtually none of these children would be considered available for adoption.

International families are not an option for the nine-year-old Ugandan prostitute, the 12-year-old Angolan "witch", the starving students in Lesotho.”

My point is, Hunger and malnutrition are a huge problem all over Africa and the rest of the developing world. However, it doesn't mean these kids are not with family that care for them and love them.

In most cases, these families are attempting to keep it together. They are still sending them to school... they are trying! These kids are not in the streets or in orphanages. Their families haven’t given them up. That is why they are not available for adoption. At least in Ethiopia, that is generally the case. Millions go hungry everyday. Millions struggle to make it to the next day with their children in tow.
PermalinkPermalink 11/24/07 @ 16:38
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
This post was about realities of life for African many, many African children. It is not to say that all African children should be adopted, but simply that adoption should be an option for those who have nothing else.

PermalinkPermalink 11/25/07 @ 00:48
Comment from: maroua [Member] Email
Sandra, we are new to this blog and have no idea as to how to post where it would be most appropriate. We recently brought our youngest daughter home from Uganda and would not mind sharing our story. You may learn more about our personal story on www.embraceuganda.org. "Embrace Uganda" is an organization we helped start after our trip to Uganda this summer, to help raise awareness for the children in this particular part of the world. There are 1,400 orphans within the organization that cared for our daughter. Please, help me navigate this site, and maybe, one or the other family could be helped by our experiences... Thank you.
PermalinkPermalink 12/17/07 @ 17:25
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

   

Misc

Subscribe to International Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 137