International Adoption Blog

05/31/07

Confronting the Nightmare

Posted by : Sandra Hanks Benoiton in International Adoption Blog at 04:53 am , 533 words, 134 views  
Categories: Adoption in the World, Related News From The World
aOAkids1/©2006GMonins
How many international adoptive parents have certain proof that their children were not stolen from their beds in the middle of the night by criminals intent on making a few bucks out of selling them on to the nearest broker?

With adoptions of Cambodian kids by Americans essentially coming to a screeching halt in December of 2001, most were completed before allegations of corruption appeared on potential adoptive parent radar. Agencies and governments were assumed to be trustworthy and honorable of intent, and people coming to the all new experience, for them, took it on faith that the hoops they jumped through had been arranged on a level course and that everyone involved had their own to negotiate correctly.

SPONSOR

When reports began to surface that all was not kosher in world of Cambodian adoption practices, many parents began to look even more closely at their children, and to wonder and worry about the circumstances that brought their family together.

In Kari Grady Grossman's book, "Bones That Float", she writes about Sovann, a Cambodian man who moves from moto driver to trusted employee over the course of her time in the country.

One of Sovann's first duties assigned by the Grossmans is to sift through the haystack that is Cambodia's abandoned children in a search for their son's birth parents. Eventually successful, Sovann has gone on to help other families locate birth parents, histories, and often most importantly, the story of how their child came to the orphanage.

In efforts to establish once and for all the truth of surrender, to address the oozing guilt many parents suffered at the though that their child may have not been relinquished by a loving but desperate mother, but rather stolen or coerced from a family that treasured the child, some have instigated the searches that Sovann and others conduct.

Sovann has found many birth parents, and so far none have had stories that run contrary to the circumstances adoptive parents had been given: death, run-away fathers, illness, no food, or some combination of all these tragic realities was the reason given on relinquishment and is the reason given years later when contact is made.

As Kari's experiences setting up the rural school her organization and book supports has proven, Cambodian birth mothers may be poor, but they aren't stupid. They would not be easily duped into handing over a child, although the thought that they might be has become popular.

The poor in India and Cambodia have far too much in common; life is grindingly difficult and children are often far more a burden than a blessing. There is no shortage of children in developing countries and they're everywhere ... on the streets, in the garbage dumps, in the brothels, in the mines.

Hundreds of thousands are orphaned. Many, many are abandoned out of desperation. Many others are sold, most to slavers of one sort or another, as those are the most aggressive recruiters with the most reliable price structure.

Who can judge the rightness or wrongness of selling one child to raise enough cash to feed others, even if the sale results in a short life of cruelty?

For more of this series, see the next post.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
"...Cambodian birth mothers may be poor, but they aren't stupid. They would not be easily duped into handing over a child..."

Plenty of women who are duped out of their children though adoption are not stupid, in fact many are very intelligent people. However, they are up against highly trained professionals who often have had years of practice.

Glad to see you writing about this subject though.
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 07:50
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
That line is pretty much a direct quote from Kari GG. Perhaps she'll drop by and expand on this.
Kari?

PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 09:14
Comment from: vivianjean [Member] Email
Does Kari say anything about these documents? The Operation Broken Hearts seems to counter the idea that some birthfamilies weren't duped.

http://www.ethicanet.org/item.php?recordid=camdocs&pagestyle=default
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 11:26
Comment from: Sunbonnet Sue [Member] Email
This is a good topic. When we adopted, our family believed we had done extensive and sufficient due diligence. Since that time, we have come to know more about the world of adoption, and can see area's where we had incomplete information. We still have incomplete information, no doubt, tho we have more than at first.

Most families whose children are in foster care, and/or later adopted, feel those children were "stolen" from them. Indeed, some children are wrongly taken. The children involved often feel as if they too have been stolen from their families.

Regardless of circumstances, these children still find themselves in need of immediate care. So far as we can gather, this remains the most important thing to focus on. Children who land in loving adoptive families have far more desirable outcomes than some of the others.
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 12:09
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
It makes me feel deeply sad that there are pockets of places where children are burdens and not blessings...

especially since I want kids right now... Poverty and those conditions breaks my heart.
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 15:16
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthfamily-search.adoptionblogs.com/
Thanks for explaining that it was not your quote, but hers.
PermalinkPermalink 05/31/07 @ 23:30
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
So sorry, but my Internet is up and down ... mostly down ... at the moment, and my email isn't working at all. I've had a note to Kari sitting in my outbox for almost 24 hours that keeps trying to go every 10 minutes, but with the rest of my mail, won't.
I'm sure she'll check in once she knows there's a question here.
Hoping I'm online long enough to post this comment ...
PermalinkPermalink 06/01/07 @ 00:12
Comment from: karig2 [Member] Email
Sorry it's taken me so long to respond to this line from my book. I just figured out RSS feeds, I'm new to the blogosphere. The line in this post appears out of context. In the book it's a summary of the social situation specific to Cambodia.

While there was certainly recruiting going on in Cambodia, along with lying and money changing hands, I do not know of any report, evidence, speculation or accusation of children being "stolen from their beds." Operators don't need to steal children in Cambodia, they are readily available, from people that they know or are very likely related too. It is a relationship oriented culture and as such, all transactions are done through a relative or someone they know. And yes, relatives often lie. My son's birthmother lied to the orphanage at reliquishment about his father being dead.
In our case and in every case that I am aware of through Sovann - the birthmother or family made a choice. Even if that choice was fueled by economic incentive which we find unethical. I have found that the women in Cambodia are very aware of how their world operates, and I think it is patronizing to assume that because they are poor and unworldly means that they can't own the choice they made. Selling a child is a choice, and in a world where you are desperate enough to do that there are many choices of whom to sell to, and they know it. If a woman feels she has made a good choice in the context of her situation in her world, who are we to rob her of ownership of her decision by asserting that she is too naïve to know better. In Cambodia, where trafficking for all sorts of things is a norm, women and their relatives are quite savvy. It is a war-torn country, with a lot of social dsyfunction. As such, love tends to manifest more as a relative instinct of survival. This has been my experience walking among the people of rural Cambodia, and I try to look at the world through their eyes. As a westerner, I work to change the desperation that fuels these choices.
- Kari
PermalinkPermalink 06/07/07 @ 12:58
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Misc

Subscribe to International Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 142