International Adoption Blog

10/22/07

Ellen Degeneres's dog has nothing to do with International Adoption

Posted by : Sandra Hanks Benoiton in International Adoption Blog at 05:59 am , 649 words, 240 views  
Categories: Adoption in the World

In the mood to read about something offensive? If so, I can recommend the blog I just posted over on the Adoption News which might have you spitting nails at UNICEF ... again.

If giant organizations with huge PR budgets and teflon coating don't set off a full round of tintinnabulation for you today, perhaps you will be more comfortable with a bit of pique for the one lone person who wrote this little piece of nincompoopiness. Titled "Foreign orphans better than ours", the writer manages to dredge up so many pin-headed statements that it's almost unbelievable that anyone could be so stupid ... but, of course, being adoptive parents, we're far too familiar with other peoples' ignorance on topics relating to children, and their willingness to broadcast rudely all aspects of said ignorance, to cling to any fantasy of a world where people educate themselves on issues as important as the inheritors of our planet.

In addition to some really weird spacing that has me wanting to introduce the concept of the paragraph ... really, honesty, every sentence does not need a new line double spaced from its neighbors ... there's a jerkiness to the thought flow, and I mean that with most every possible definition of the word 'jerk' in mind. (Keeping in mind, of course, that accepted blog style does suggest frequent breaks and stand-alone sentences, so I'm not exactly practicing what I preach on this one.)

From Oprah to Angelina to Ellen DeGeneres's dog, it's kitchen sink time on the orphan front with little regard to connecting the dots and an apparent wish to offend as wide an audience as possible.

But why do we have to bribe someone to take care of American kids when folks with millions are willing to pay big money for foreign children?

And why isn't this part of the great immigration debate?

I mean, if it's wrong for people to cross our borders to take our jobs, shouldn't it be wrong for our people to cross our borders to buy someone else's children?

Buy American children first.

SPONSOR


Okay, maybe this is satire and I'm taking it too seriously .... please! ... but do any of us doubt this stinky thinking exists?

Since this is out and about in the world today, thanks to the guy with the bad, rude 'tude, perhaps we should spend a minute thinking about ways to address this ignorance when we meet it face-to-face.

The questions often start with the "Why did you go all the way to ______ (Fill in the blank with your child's birth country), when there are so many American kids that need homes? (To be honest, I don't deal with this because I don't live in America, but I am imaginative enough to conjure a version of myself in that position and come up with what I could hear myself saying.)

Depending on the specific circumstance, your personality and how close you are to blowing up over the rest of the stresses in your day, you could trot out one or more of the following retorts:

• What's it to ya, Bozo?

• Is there something in my face that makes you think I'll feel obliged to answer such a personal question?

• Before going any further, could I please introduce you to my visible, aware and hearing child? Child, this is an adult who has yet to learn where his/her world leaves off and other peoples' worlds begin. Adult, this is good-bye.

• I'm sorry, but I wasn't aware that American children are more deserving of families than those in other countries.

• And how many children have YOU adopted from foster care ... ?

Okay, there are kinder, gentler responses, but given the day I've been having my imagination is stopping just short of coming up with any of those.

Please feel free to contribute any and all you might have.

I need to stop reading so much of the news ...

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Faith Allen [Member] Email · http://hoping.adoptionblogs.com/
It is amazing how judgmental people can be when they have not walked in your shoes. Any avenue to parenthood through adoption comes with challenges, and most of the judgmental folks don't know a thing about those challenges.

I love your retort, "And how many children have YOU adopted from foster care ... ?" because that pretty much sums it all up. The people I know who have adopted out of foster care tell others to really do their homework before going that route.

Good post!

- Faith
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 06:16
Comment from: Sunbonnet Sue [Member] Email
we use the "how many have you adopted from foster care" train of thought a lot. especially with folks who like to inform us of everything we are doing wrong in our parenting attempts........
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 08:25
Comment from: Kelly [Member] Email · http://fost-adopt.adoptionblogs.com
Love the comebacks Sandra. I think I'll save a few of those, even though my kids are "home grown".
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 08:57
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
these folks do not live in the real world, i swear they do not. Can they really be that clueless to not know about these situations?
It doesn't seem to be that easy to adopt from foster care either.
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 09:30
Comment from: MamaS [Member] Email
I once used "But, my daughters ARE Americans! They just happen to have been born in El Salvador." We finished shopping and were long gone before the nincompoop worked that one out!
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 10:57
Comment from: Kansas Girl [Member] Email
Article style points aside, I did agree with the writer of "Foreign orphans better than ours". It always amazes me how much this issue inflames folks on both sides of the coin – just look at the postings so far. And, instead of just trashing this guy’s article, why don’t you try to educate him on why Americans go overseas to adopt? The wonderful thing about America is that we do have the choice of domestic vs. international adoption. Do I feel more righteous adopting “American”? No, I don’t feel that it makes me any better than anyone else. I’m not a “do-gooder” and don’t want to be seen as one. I am just interested in making the U.S. a better place to live for its citizens, especially those who are citizens by birth, whether they are born to U.S. citizens or immigrants. This isn’t the same as “buy American” - we’re not talking about a car here or protecting U.S. jobs – we’re talking about helping those who are already in this country who can’t speak for themselves yet. For myself, taking care of these children is a responsibility that’s right up there with the right to vote and all that good stuff - it’s just the right thing to do. It affects all of us – from the cost of running the foster care system to rising prison populations and crime rates. I’d like to say I did my part to reducing the prison population in the U.S. even if by one – that’s where my son would have ended up had he aged out of the system. He’s a very smart individual who didn’t deserve his start in life – hopefully now he has an opportunity for a successful (emotionally healthy) life. Why not help out your own country? Why not make your own country stronger by helping those citizens who need help? What is wrong with being patriotic?
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 13:37
Comment from: Chromesthesia [Member] Email
Why not do both?
I want the foster care system to be reformed NOW. But I also want to help children in Guatemala and Russia, and Africa... ect
Children are children to me, but it does make our country better to help children here...

Adoption though is not about helping kids but starting families.
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 19:19
Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
Kansas Girl,

I had neither the time, nor the inclination, to try to educate this guy yesterday. Some people really aren't worth the effort and I have limited energy at the moment.

You have made some interesting points, but I have to say that I, for one, have a problem with the thought of adopting as a patriotic duty.

Congratulations on your son and your family. It sounds like you made the right choices for all of you.
PermalinkPermalink 10/22/07 @ 21:07
Comment from: Lisa [Member] Email · http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com
Kansas Girl wrote:
"I am just interested in making the U.S. a better place to live for its citizens, especially those who are citizens by birth, whether they are born to U.S. citizens or immigrants."

I guess as a naturalized citizen and mother of naturalized bio sons and a naturalized Guatemalan born daughter, I find this sentence just a little offensive.

But then again, since I wasn't "born" into my citizenship, it is probably "okay" for me to adopt from abroad, right?

Lisa S.
http://guatemala.adoptionblogs.com
PermalinkPermalink 10/24/07 @ 22:01
Comment from: Kansas Girl [Member] Email
Lisa - you can do whatever you want....that's what so wonderful about this country. I'm sorry if I offended you or anyone...not my intent. Just wanted to voice my opinion. To quote my own post: "I am just interested in making the U.S. a better place to live for its citizens" - which would include you - and "we’re talking about helping those who are already in this country who can’t speak for themselves yet". The point of Phil's article and my post is that not enough people in America care about helping their fellow citizens - I find that not only sad, but a tragedy. Dr. Bruce Perry, one of the leading authorities/researchers on the affects of trauma (abuse & neglect) on the developing brain, calls it "de-evolution". I'd rather not see it happen to our country, though sadly I'm afraid it's already happening. Not enough people seem to care that the foster care system is a mess, our prison populations continue to grow, and there are way too many hurting families in this country. I just try to do my part - through my adopted family, and through other volunteer work with at risk teenagers.

BTW, if adoption is only about starting a family, I'll take two kids, a boy and a girl, both with red hair and green eyes so they look just like my husband and I. However, for me and my husband, adoption has been (and will continue to be) helping a child by giving one without a home that family they want. Why not do both - why not start a family and help a child at the same time - isn't the "mere" act of giving a child a home helping that child, and isn't that what we're all doing anyway?

BTW, my son is Hispanic and is from California. He could have ancestors from Mexico, they could be Native American from the southwestern U.S. - hopefully someday we will be able to figure that out.
PermalinkPermalink 10/25/07 @ 14:12
Comment from: soblessed [Member] Email
Kansas Girl:

"The point of Phil's article and my post is that not enough people in America care about helping their fellow citizens"

You're entitled, of course, to your opinion, but I'm not so sure that Americans are sitting back on their La-Z-Boys and ordering up a few foreign children to the exclusion of the waif next door. On a personal note, I provide a home to a child not my own four days and nights out of seven at a minimum. I also provide vacations, holidays, an extended family, summer camp, paren-teacher conferences, a small account for college someday and all the love, acceptance, hugs, kisses and affection that he wants. As a teacher in the public schools, I see many, many parents step up to the plate to do what they can to make sure that the children of neighbors and friends have what they need when their parents can't--or won't-- provide it themselves. These are not formal arrangement; they are just people helping other people because they feel called to it. Just like I felt called to international adoption when it came time for us to adopt. And I did it for several reasons; some of which are personal and I don't always choose to share with everyone. Maybe the Americans adopting overseas are not so much uncaring as they are responding to their own situation in the way that is best for them. Not everyone in America is well-suited for domestic adoption.

I most definitely do not regret adopting my son from Guatemala....he is the best fit for our family....and he deserves a chance in life just as much as his American born neighbors.

PermalinkPermalink 10/25/07 @ 17:47
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

   

Misc

Subscribe to International Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • sam1900
  • Guest Users: 163